MaxCell 1700mAh battery

Hi,

I bought one of the MaxCell 1700mAh batteries on ebay about 3 months ago and
it seems to have completely died. I was never convinced it actually lasted
much longer than the original battery (I had to charge up the1700 every
three days at least, more often if I had bluetooth turned on), then
yesterday I had just charged it up and was sending an SMS message when the
whole phone went dead. I tried turning it on again but nothing happened. I
put the original battery back in and the phone worked again straight away.
Has this happened to anyone else (yet), that after about 3 months their 1700
battery just died?

Thanks

Eric

I've had mine for 3 months too but no problem with it dying like that. I
have noticed that it's not lasting as long as it did initially though. That
could be due to changes in my usage which I'll have to examine when I get my
next bill.

"Eric Baber" <eric@netlearnlanguages.com> wrote in message
news:3ttn0nFt5ct3U1@individual.net...
> Hi,
>
> I bought one of the MaxCell 1700mAh batteries on ebay about 3 months ago
> and it seems to have completely died. I was never convinced it actually
> lasted much longer than the original battery (I had to charge up the1700
> every three days at least, more often if I had bluetooth turned on), then
> yesterday I had just charged it up and was sending an SMS message when the
> whole phone went dead. I tried turning it on again but nothing happened. I
> put the original battery back in and the phone worked again straight away.
> Has this happened to anyone else (yet), that after about 3 months their
> 1700 battery just died?
>
> Thanks
>
> Eric
>

In message <oBoef.21704$th3.13074@tornado.texas.rr.com> "brobin"
<nospam@atmyplace.com> wrote:

>I've had mine for 3 months too but no problem with it dying like that. I
>have noticed that it's not lasting as long as it did initially though. That
>could be due to changes in my usage which I'll have to examine when I get my
>next bill.

Interesting -- I was thinking about posting this morning about this same
issue. When I got mine I was getting 3+ days of "full charge", and
somewhere between the 3rd and the beginning of the 5th day the phone
would die.

I did a full charge yesterday, my alarm went off around 8am this
morning, the phone was dead (as in off) by noon.

I popped the factory battery back in for the moment, I'll try the other
one again in a couple days, but it looks like the short lifespan might
not be just me

--
In case of accidental ingestion, consult a mortician.

"DevilsPGD" <spam_narf_spam@crazyhat.net> wrote in message
news:lpgkn1dj7364gmtv0rratcd29j9m63ced9@4ax.com...
> In message <oBoef.21704$th3.13074@tornado.texas.rr.com> "brobin"
> <nospam@atmyplace.com> wrote:
>
> >I've had mine for 3 months too but no problem with it dying like that. I
> >have noticed that it's not lasting as long as it did initially though.
That
> >could be due to changes in my usage which I'll have to examine when I get
my
> >next bill.
>
> Interesting -- I was thinking about posting this morning about this same
> issue. When I got mine I was getting 3+ days of "full charge", and
> somewhere between the 3rd and the beginning of the 5th day the phone
> would die.
>
> I did a full charge yesterday, my alarm went off around 8am this
> morning, the phone was dead (as in off) by noon.
>
> I popped the factory battery back in for the moment, I'll try the other
> one again in a couple days, but it looks like the short lifespan might
> not be just me

It'll be interesting to see what happens when you try it again. I've just
tried charging up the 1700 again in the stand-alone charger, then putting it
back into the phone, and it's dead as a doornail - not a peep. Seems it's
completely snuffed it.

Eric

Try removing it from the phone for a few seconds and see if it works when
you put it back in.

"Eric Baber" <Eric@netlearnlanguages.com> wrote in message
news:3u15ngFv4qacU1@individual.net...
> "DevilsPGD" <spam_narf_spam@crazyhat.net> wrote in message
> news:lpgkn1dj7364gmtv0rratcd29j9m63ced9@4ax.com...
>> In message <oBoef.21704$th3.13074@tornado.texas.rr.com> "brobin"
>> <nospam@atmyplace.com> wrote:
>>
>> >I've had mine for 3 months too but no problem with it dying like that. I
>> >have noticed that it's not lasting as long as it did initially though.
> That
>> >could be due to changes in my usage which I'll have to examine when I
>> >get
> my
>> >next bill.
>>
>> Interesting -- I was thinking about posting this morning about this same
>> issue. When I got mine I was getting 3+ days of "full charge", and
>> somewhere between the 3rd and the beginning of the 5th day the phone
>> would die.
>>
>> I did a full charge yesterday, my alarm went off around 8am this
>> morning, the phone was dead (as in off) by noon.
>>
>> I popped the factory battery back in for the moment, I'll try the other
>> one again in a couple days, but it looks like the short lifespan might
>> not be just me
>
> It'll be interesting to see what happens when you try it again. I've just
> tried charging up the 1700 again in the stand-alone charger, then putting
> it
> back into the phone, and it's dead as a doornail - not a peep. Seems it's
> completely snuffed it.
>
> Eric
>
>

"brobin" <nospam@atmyplace.com> wrote in message
news:wrJef.18921$3K6.3410@tornado.texas.rr.com...
> Try removing it from the phone for a few seconds and see if it works when
> you put it back in.

Have done, hasn't done any good.

Eric

In message <3u15ngFv4qacU1@individual.net> "Eric Baber"
<Eric@netlearnlanguages.com> wrote:

>"DevilsPGD" <spam_narf_spam@crazyhat.net> wrote in message
>news:lpgkn1dj7364gmtv0rratcd29j9m63ced9@4ax.com.. .
>> In message <oBoef.21704$th3.13074@tornado.texas.rr.com> "brobin"
>> <nospam@atmyplace.com> wrote:
>>
>> >I've had mine for 3 months too but no problem with it dying like that. I
>> >have noticed that it's not lasting as long as it did initially though.
>That
>> >could be due to changes in my usage which I'll have to examine when I get
>my
>> >next bill.
>>
>> Interesting -- I was thinking about posting this morning about this same
>> issue. When I got mine I was getting 3+ days of "full charge", and
>> somewhere between the 3rd and the beginning of the 5th day the phone
>> would die.
>>
>> I did a full charge yesterday, my alarm went off around 8am this
>> morning, the phone was dead (as in off) by noon.
>>
>> I popped the factory battery back in for the moment, I'll try the other
>> one again in a couple days, but it looks like the short lifespan might
>> not be just me
>
>It'll be interesting to see what happens when you try it again. I've just
>tried charging up the 1700 again in the stand-alone charger, then putting it
>back into the phone, and it's dead as a doornail - not a peep. Seems it's
>completely snuffed it.

I'll try that now, I won't need the phone for a few hours and I can
handle it dying tomorrow if it happens. Mine has always been charged in
the phone, never in an external charger.

--
Light travels faster than sound. This is why some people appear
bright until you hear them speak...

"Eric Baber" <eric@netlearnlanguages.com> wrote in message
news:3ttn0nFt5ct3U1@individual.net...
> Hi,
>
> I bought one of the MaxCell 1700mAh batteries on ebay about 3 months ago
and
> it seems to have completely died. I was never convinced it actually lasted
> much longer than the original battery (I had to charge up the1700 every
> three days at least, more often if I had bluetooth turned on), then
> yesterday I had just charged it up and was sending an SMS message when the
> whole phone went dead. I tried turning it on again but nothing happened. I
> put the original battery back in and the phone worked again straight away.
> Has this happened to anyone else (yet), that after about 3 months their
1700
> battery just died?
>
> Thanks
>
> Eric
>
>

doesn't these have a lifetime warranty?
i was thinking about getting one but maybe not now hehe.

In message <z7SdndFSxekBoeHenZ2dnUVZ_sGdnZ2d@comcast.com> "Aaron"
<aarons6@hotmail.com> wrote:

>doesn't these have a lifetime warranty?

A battery with a lifetime warranty? Doubtful...

--
Going to church doesn't make you a christian any more than
standing in a garage makes you a car.

On Tue, 15 Nov 2005 13:51:49 -0700, DevilsPGD
<spam_narf_spam@crazyhat.net> wrote:

>I popped the factory battery back in for the moment, I'll try the other
>one again in a couple days, but it looks like the short lifespan might
>not be just me

I'm going through a similar deal now with a 3rd party
monster size StarTAC battery.
There is no way to know if these monster mAh ratings
are real!
Yours may say 1700, yet really be 700.
Similar with my 1400.

In message <05fqn19n2bq4ocku2ba9u93l4amshsluci@4ax.com>
clemslay@iname.com wrote:

>On Tue, 15 Nov 2005 13:51:49 -0700, DevilsPGD
><spam_narf_spam@crazyhat.net> wrote:
>
>>I popped the factory battery back in for the moment, I'll try the other
>>one again in a couple days, but it looks like the short lifespan might
>>not be just me
>
>I'm going through a similar deal now with a 3rd party
>monster size StarTAC battery.
>There is no way to know if these monster mAh ratings
>are real!
>Yours may say 1700, yet really be 700.
>Similar with my 1400.

While true, you can take a reasonable guess. If it lasts longer then
the factory battery under the same usage conditions, it's probably a
higher mAh then the factory battery.

Not scientific, but still useful.

--
Why is a person who plays the piano called a pianist,
but a person who drives a race car isn't called a racist?