I say w300i. It has better internet (
EDGE vs class 6
GPRS), better camera (VGA interpolated to 1.3mp vs VGA), over twice the battery life (talk time 9 hours vs 4 hours), better screen (256k vs 64k), smaller and lighter, far newer, far more memory (20+256 vs 6+32)... And judging by it's design and SE's reputation, I assume it is far more durable.. Wouldn't you expect that it would be, compared to a flip phone with a twisting screen? Don't get caught on the smartphone capabilities, symbian is somewhat buggy, and there are literally hundreds of java apps you can download for w300i. Not to mention, the mp3 player in the nokia sucks.. Mono? that means you plug your ONE-sided earpiece into the phone and listen to music through that. And forget about an easy interface for mp3s.. This looks like a no-brainer to me, w300i.