For $5.99 a month, Total Equipment Coverage from Verizon (through Asurion) covers water damage, breakage, loss and theft. It also extends the manufacturer's warranty so you won't pay the deductible if the problem is not caused by abuse/misuse.
All in all, it is well worth it for phones with a full retail replacement cost of $200.00 or more.
Also, since I know it will come up, the loss and theft coverage no longer requires a Police report be filed.