P910i versus P900

Apart from the multimedia features like clearer screens and camera, if you
do a product compare at SE Website
it appears that P900 is a better phone.
Also a 1 Gig memory card will probably cost as much as the phone.

Anyone has comments contrary to this?

views please...thanks

---

› See More: P910i versus P900

On 1-Oct-2004, "stan" <[email protected]> wrote:

> Apart from the multimedia features like clearer screens and camera, if you
>
> do a product compare at SE Website
> it appears that P900 is a better phone.
> Also a 1 Gig memory card will probably cost as much as the phone.
>
> Anyone has comments contrary to this?
>
> views please...thanks

How exactly is it better?
I've had a P900 and now got a P910. The P910 has a much brighter screen,
useful extra RAM. The keyboard is a bit of a gimmick but all in all it is
better than the P900. Whether upgrading is worthwhile I'm not sure though.

<[email protected]> wrote:
>
> [clip] Whether upgrading is worthwhile I'm not sure though.

Now that is honest and useful comment.
I have a P900 now, and am kindo eager to upgrade to P910 - but the sensible
part of me says that it's not worth the dough now.
I have no real reason to upgrade (don't need 1 gig, screen is ok, don't use
cam) - but then again I want the latest.
Your comment is appreciated - I'll hold (for a while).

On 1-Oct-2004, "Nuke" <[email protected]> wrote:

> >
> > [clip] Whether upgrading is worthwhile I'm not sure though.
>
> Now that is honest and useful comment.
> I have a P900 now, and am kindo eager to upgrade to P910 - but the
> sensible
> part of me says that it's not worth the dough now.
> I have no real reason to upgrade (don't need 1 gig, screen is ok, don't
> use
> cam) - but then again I want the latest.
> Your comment is appreciated - I'll hold (for a while).

I sold my P900 and a K700i which gave me nearly enough to buy (cost me £525)
so wasn't really a problem for me and as an upgrade it is no way in the same
league as p800 to p900. The extra RAM is very useful and the screen does
look much clearer but all told the changes aren't really worth it I think. I
doubt I will ever use the QWERTY keyboard which really seems the main
hardware change. I think if you want to look at upgrading then you need to
see it in the flesh as it is a bit different, flip is little deeper and the
p900 keys look better I think.

It is pretty cheap though, prices have dropped a heck of a lot quicker than
the p900 did. I mean, I've seen it for £450 now. It's probabaly cheaper to
buy than some places are selling the P800 for.

I went straight from the P800 to the P910i. A world of difference but can't
comment on the P900 itself

--

<[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
>
> On 1-Oct-2004, "Nuke" <[email protected]> wrote:
>
>> >
>> > [clip] Whether upgrading is worthwhile I'm not sure though.
>>
>> Now that is honest and useful comment.
>> I have a P900 now, and am kindo eager to upgrade to P910 - but the
>> sensible
>> part of me says that it's not worth the dough now.
>> I have no real reason to upgrade (don't need 1 gig, screen is ok, don't
>> use
>> cam) - but then again I want the latest.
>> Your comment is appreciated - I'll hold (for a while).
>
> I sold my P900 and a K700i which gave me nearly enough to buy (cost me
> £525)
> so wasn't really a problem for me and as an upgrade it is no way in the
> same
> league as p800 to p900. The extra RAM is very useful and the screen does
> look much clearer but all told the changes aren't really worth it I think.
> I
> doubt I will ever use the QWERTY keyboard which really seems the main
> hardware change. I think if you want to look at upgrading then you need to
> see it in the flesh as it is a bit different, flip is little deeper and
> the
> p900 keys look better I think.
>
> It is pretty cheap though, prices have dropped a heck of a lot quicker
> than
> the p900 did. I mean, I've seen it for £450 now. It's probabaly cheaper to
> buy than some places are selling the P800 for.

Is the AvantGo application included on the CD-ROM the Beta version offered
on AvantGo's site or is it the full version? Thanks.

<[email protected]> wrote in message
news:[email protected]...
>
> On 1-Oct-2004, "stan" <[email protected]> wrote:
>
>> Apart from the multimedia features like clearer screens and camera, if
>> you
>>
>> do a product compare at SE Website
>> it appears that P900 is a better phone.
>> Also a 1 Gig memory card will probably cost as much as the phone.
>>
>> Anyone has comments contrary to this?
>>
>> views please...thanks
>
> How exactly is it better?
> I've had a P900 and now got a P910. The P910 has a much brighter screen,
> useful extra RAM. The keyboard is a bit of a gimmick but all in all it is
> better than the P900. Whether upgrading is worthwhile I'm not sure though.

The P910i supports both Bluetooth Headset and BT Handsfree profile, the P900
only supports Headset.
So the P910 now works ok with Bluetooth carkits from all brands, even the
build-in ones in BMW's etc.
Bernd

"stan" <[email protected]> schreef in bericht
news:[email protected]...
> Apart from the multimedia features like clearer screens and camera, if you
> do a product compare at SE Website
> it appears that P900 is a better phone.
> Also a 1 Gig memory card will probably cost as much as the phone.
>
> Anyone has comments contrary to this?
>
> views please...thanks
>
>

On Sat, 02 Oct 2004 19:09:25 +0200, Bernd wrote:

> The P910i supports both Bluetooth Headset and BT Handsfree profile, the P900
> only supports Headset.

That's poor design ain't it ? The SE p900 not supporting the BT
'handsfree' profile. Especially as just about every other BT enabled SE
phone supports this profile, same with BT enabled Nokias.

It would render the call-list screen feature of the SE HBH-200 headset
useless when used with a p900.

<snipped>

--
Michael Turner
Email (ROT13)
[email protected]

Bernd wrote:

> The P910i supports both Bluetooth Headset and BT Handsfree profile, the P900
> only supports Headset.
> So the P910 now works ok with Bluetooth carkits from all brands, even the
> build-in ones in BMW's etc.
> Bernd

???
I've used my P900 in my car with the bluetooth car kit for over 1.5
years (it also worked with the P800).
So what do you mean that the P900 doesn't support BT Handsfree profile?

Regards
Jean-Yves