Midi vs MP3 and WAV

Is it jus me or do all of you feel that midi tones are the ****?? MP3 just wack...

---

› See More: Midi vs MP3 and WAV

mp3 wayyyy better, its the actual thing rather than a crapper version

i have to put up with it though with my t610...lucky for the p800 then.. Hidden Content

midi is good when you want an instramental. MP3 is good for songs, Wavs take up too much space. midis sound good on most phones, MP3s only sound good on phones with a good speaker. Such as my phone.

MP3 is way better

Depends on the phone, I have da 6630 and da Midi sounds brilliant on it! But i use the occasional mp3 tone.

Hidden Content Originally Posted by Mark

Depends on the phone, I have da 6630 and da Midi sounds brilliant on it! But i use the occasional mp3 tone.

yeah , me 2 ,i say midi is best , then mp3 , cause midi is the thing that can go on all latest phones beside the fact some of them cant take mp3

wav sucks because the files are too big. midi sounds too generic. << mp3 ringers, real sound clips from the actual song, and size is good, not too big at all. hell, i have over 35 mp3 ringers on mine. I am still needing to get my phone unlocked, that way i can delete all the midi ringers on here that came with the phone.

Hidden Content Originally Posted by tooldef6

wav sucks because the files are too big. midi sounds too generic. << mp3 ringers, real sound clips from the actual song, and size is good, not too big at all. hell, i have over 35 mp3 ringers on mine. I am still needing to get my phone unlocked, that way i can delete all the midi ringers on here that came with the phone.

yes thats true but midi is more common, and well mp3 is best but not most common because its on less phones, oh and tooldef 6 can u fufill my request in da mp3 ringers thread u made please?

considered fullfilled lazy underfire.

well i like mp3's cuz im a perfectionist, and midis just sound too weird. they have to be right, and they are not. so im gunna have to go with mp3.

theres a limit to not only what u can DO with midis but what you can HAVE as a midi ringtone because a midi of everything simply doesn't exist. besides that, they sound like Nintendo games. midis are only good if your phone doesn't support MP3 files. with MP3s you can have ANYthing u want as a ringtone, it doesn't even have to be music, you can have jokes, sound efx, or even your own personal recordings. basically if it exists in the real world then u can have it as a ringer if you choose to. why anyone would say midis are better than MP3s is quite confusing to me, yea they sound cool if ur the type that likes electronic music, especially on a phone that supports a high number of chords but MP3s are 'real.' as for WAV files, well they just suck.

Hidden Content Originally Posted by Mr_Jon

MP3 is way better

shyeah what he said.

wav r way too big, mp3's r da ****

I've never tried wav, only mp3 and midi. mp3s are better than midi.

Mp3s are way better but my phone can't cope with it Hidden Content