I recently traded to get a 5S (T-Mobile 16GB Space grey) with charger and silicone case. I traded the previous owner with a T-Mobile 32GB SIII with box and basic accessories, a very used HTC Radar, and an out-of-battery Itouch 2nd gen with two silicone cases. Was this a good deal?

Keep in mind:
-the iPhone is clean, paid off
-has tiny back nicks
-originally bought the SIII for 200, after a $60 net profit from previously selling 2 S3's 16gb
-gave $40 to sister to in order to trade the Radar

Thank you!