Give it to Dwayne Wade... Look what he has done...Miami has gone farther into the playoffs than the Nuggets and the Cavs (o ya..Cavs didn't go). In head to head match ups....Wade outshined the others.

Carmello had similar stats, played in the west and made the playoffs. Much more deserving than Bron.

It should be Carmelo's award...

i think carmello anthony should of gotten da award b/c Lebron plays in a musc "easier" side then carmello and to me carmello did much better den lebron

Originally posted by X²
even though LeBron had neither

he sure didnt

I love both of them. I think they are the best but i rather Lebron James. He deserved it.

lebron definitely deserved it. his numbers were awesome for a 19 year old. give this guy a few years to mature and he will be amazing.

carmello most def deserved it more...

while lebron is out at parties carmello is still playing basketball in the playoffs....

he won it because he was hyped way more than carmello and carmello did better in clutch times....

the cavs would come close to compteting in the west....

the east is really soft

even though LeBron had neither

LeBron James, the super-hyped phenom who went from high school to the pros and kept the Cleveland Cavaliers in playoff contention until late in the season, has beaten out Carmelo Anthony in voting for the NBA's Rookie of the Year award.

A source with knowledge of the vote tally, speaking on condition of anonymity, said James will be presented with the award Tuesday.

http://sports.yahoo.com/nba/news;_yl...v=ap&type=lgns

the writers seem to change their mind every year whether to award ROTY to the guy w/ the best stats or the guy that makes their team record better

its almost official and i'm sure he will be even though i thought carmelo would do it... what do u think?