curtain call is just a greatest hits compilation with one okay track (when i'm gone) and two rather off-beat ones that are more like the garbage on his last album (FACK and Shake That)... Eminem's been off for a while and "When I'm Gone" isn't enough to convince me that he's back.

Slim Shady and Infinite...Eminem got worse and worse with each album. Encore was complete garbage. But to be honest, I'm not really an Eminem fan...

Yeah i think I heard that one song. It's about his daughter I think. I was in the car and I was driving and I was crying!

Do you people think that the new songs on curtain call will be good? i have listened to all three and i think the best is When I'm GOne

Don't you think that the Curtain Call will be the best? since it has all his top songs

THE MARSHALL MATHERS LP was HOOOOOOTTTTT, it's his best one
I haven't heard INFINITE, and THE SLIM SHADY LP (tough I love the singles from it)
THE EMINEM SHOW was good
ENCORE isn't his best effort, was a disapointement to me, he isn"t original anymore.

Encore, by far. . .

marshall mathers lp

well theres a freestyle cd with proof and dre it is hot i cant rememba da name tho

Wich underground one are ya talking about?

i think da underground album was wanna d best but y'all did not add da poll 4 that ,so i say marshall mathers LP cause dats my second choice

The Marshall Mathers LP

Encore

I'd say he reached the top on Marshall Mathers LP... it's a shame he has never reached that high again!

Eminem Show, stole the show to me

i'm starting to think it's better than encore. i listened to it a hell of a lot longer than encore, that's for sure.